Home
Subscribe
About
Us
Features
Past
Features
News
Album
Reviews
Movie
Reviews
Concert
Reviews
Book
Reviews
Contact
Us
|
Single
Serving
A PsychoSONGanalysis by
psychologist, Dr Bruce L. Thiessen, aka Dr BLT
Song: Should I Stay or Should
I Go
Band: The Clash
To set the tone for this
review, please tune in to this cover of the song by yours truly:
Should I Stay or Should
I Go
Dr BLT
http://www.drblt.net/music/ShouldIStayDrBLT.mp3
Darling you got to let
me know
Should I stay or should
I go?
If you say that you are
mine
I’ll be here ’til the
end of time
So you got to let me
know
Should I stay or should
I go?
In this song, the Clash
perfectly, and passionately depict the phenomenon of “mixed signals,” that
are prevalent in many, if not most intimate relationships. They also
capture, quite poignantly, the phenomenon of ambivalence.
A certain level of ambivalence
in relationships is quite normal, given that human beings seem to inherently
struggle with a clash (no pun intended) between individual expression and
independence, on the one hand, and, the need to be intimately connected
with others, on the other.
Furthermore, there is generally
one person, more, ostensibly dependent in a relationship, and another more,
ostensibly independent.
Taken to the extreme, ambivalence
in relationships signals psychopathology. What does psychopathic
ambivalence look like? Think of the song, “Thin Line between Love
and Hate.” Pretenders did a great remake of that song. Listen
to it, and you’ll learn that if you’re at the wrong end of a borderline
personality disorder, or you’ve pushed the boundaries in accordance with
your own psychopathological ambivalence, you could end up in a hospital
bed just a heartbeat from your death bed. If the love isn’t fed,
and the hate is furthered, love/hate relationships can become dangerous.
Always tease tease tease
You’re happy when I’m
on my knees
One day is fine, next
day is black
So if you want me off
your back
Well come on and let
me know
Should I stay or should
I go?
Bipolar disorder and Borderline
Personality Disorder commonly go together. Bipolar disorder emphasizes
mood instability, and Borderline Personality Disorder is more of a deep-seated
character problem, and emphasizes instability in relationships. Of
course unstable moods can easily fuel instability in relationships.
When you “tease tease tease,”
in relationships, the ambivalence you feel is usually waited on the hate
side of the love/hate side of the love/hate relationship equation.
A teaser is afraid of intimacy, but craves attention and is generally a
thrill-seeker. Beware of the tease. And those who seek teases
may not be so psychologically sound themselves. They are often depressed
and seek significant (ambivalent) others to give them a rush of adrenaline.
Should I stay or should
I go now?
Should I stay or should
I go now?
If I go there will be
trouble
An’ if I stay it will
be double
So come on and let me
know!
If you feel you are a victim
in an abusive relationship, the question of whether to stay or to go should
be obvious. Duh? Go, before they kill you, either physically,
or psychologically. But it’s very complicated for the victim.
They are often realistically afraid of what the abusing party is capable
of. They often realistically don’t trust that the law will consistently
protect them if they decide to leave.
If you are a victim of abuse,
the answer is to find a way to find the strength and support systems to
leave, so that if it comes down to that, you will never return to the hell
you are presently in.
Seek support from friends,
seek legal support, and, if necessarily, seek professional help in the
form of psychotherapy, including group and individual treatment.
The Clash articulate AMBIVALENCE
and internal conflict with profound deftness, poignancy and clarity in
this classic, punk-influenced song. It speaks to a universal dilemma----the
quintessential dilemma of our generation. Should I Stay or Should
I Go?
|